I use the second one, bought it at Makro about a year ago when the compressor I had been using for around 30 years packed in. I have had no issues so far. My only criticism is that it is quite loud but fills the tank quite quickly and you get a lot of spraying done from a full load so is not too much of an issue.
On a lighter note it has an autostart feature that once the pressure drops to a certain level it switches on to fill again. I nearly crap myself each time it happens
Just remember to switch it off once full and turn it on manually!